Challenge Ended
Creepy Conversation Starters
I had a Halloween party this past year and filled a pumpkin pail with folded pieces of paper and each one had a creepy question or conversation starter. For example...If you were a serial killer, what "trophies" would you take from your victimes? If you were a cannibal, what would be your favorite body part to eat? What's your favorite murder show on TV? What kind of ghost would you be? What competition would you choose if you had to challenge the Devil and win back your soul? Post your own creepy question for the challenge and answer other Prosers questions in their comments. I'll award the best question AND the best answer to a question.
Ended August 5, 2023 • 14 Entries • Created by PrettyScaries
Challenge
Creepy Conversation Starters
I had a Halloween party this past year and filled a pumpkin pail with folded pieces of paper and each one had a creepy question or conversation starter. For example...If you were a serial killer, what "trophies" would you take from your victimes? If you were a cannibal, what would be your favorite body part to eat? What's your favorite murder show on TV? What kind of ghost would you be? What competition would you choose if you had to challenge the Devil and win back your soul? Post your own creepy question for the challenge and answer other Prosers questions in their comments. I'll award the best question AND the best answer to a question.
Eyes on Target
I am watching the bowl and I saw you pick this up so now you are it. Either you walk out of here with another person's pinky to deposit in your kitchen garbage disposal before midnight tonight or you deposit you own pinky in the kitchen garbage disposal by midnight tonight. Failure to do either of these options will result in your death in 3 days.
EmeraldGreen
Fuck you. Come get me. Doors open and I got my balisong, pendejo.
InvisibleWriter
I scoff, throwing the paper threat behind me. Pinkies in the garbage disposal? Child’s play. I’ve already got bodies piling up in the cellar. They’re asking for a pinky? I wonder what they’ll do with an entire hand.
PrettyScaries
hehehehehhehee
minou
So remember when you pinky promised not to tell Mom about the broken vase? And she magically found out? Yeah, I'm going to cash out on that pinky, please!
Melpomene
Invite my friends over for a sleepover and while they sleep I'll cut off their pinkies. But before they wake up, I'll replace them with plastic ones so they can't blame me for anything.
PrettyScaries
Does it count i f the pinky comes from someone who is already dead? I'm hoping yes, because that's easy